25 CPS wrote: ↑Tue Aug 27, 2024 1:44 pm
AVGresponding wrote: ↑Sat Aug 24, 2024 9:08 am
That radio looks cool, and it's nice to see AM/FM stations still alive, in these days of trashy DAB
We actually don't have DAB here anymore.
Good, mostly. No, but seriously. DAB (backronymed as "Dead At Birth" by some here) was promising. Until people started to realise what kind of transmitter density was required, and what costs were associated with quality audio. The codec is respectable, if and only if, one keeps bitrate up at 256kbit/s. And you can't swap the codec, except by fork lift upgrading everyone. One reason for DAB is that every second to eighth channel in the multiplex is essentially free. And then channel no 9 will cost as much as channel 1. This is because a DAB multiplex is a 2Mbit E1 TDM package in which the channels are multiplexed in time slots; you must transmit the entire package and as long as there are slots free you can add programs, essentially for free. Guess what the commercial broadcasters did? They waited for my old employer to build out their 4 channels and then fought like hell to get one of the remaining slots, without causing the 9th to be built. The other reason has to do with multi path distortion. In mountain country, DAB will be more effective than FM, simply because multi path reception is cumulatively good, not destructive as in analog. Hence, Norway and Switzerland had good reasons to build it. The rest, not so much.
25 CPS wrote: ↑Tue Aug 27, 2024 1:44 pm
The result of DAB completely flopping here left the status quo of analog AM and FM going.
Also, good. Mostly. FM still is better. And this from the quality issues and also from robustness.
25 CPS wrote: ↑Tue Aug 27, 2024 1:44 pm
Pop/top 40 music on AM held on for a very long time here due to CRTC regulations about the kind of content that could be played on FM until the early to mid-1990s.
The last station that worked AM here was talk only, somewhat focused on transmissions toward Eastern Europe. Pity it has been decommissioned -- having an AM station telling the truth in Russian would have been an asset.
Now, why am I so negative? Well, the Internet won. If we're keeping something non-IP, it might as well be very resilient and not as sensitive as DAB. Also, on the Internet, the use of codec is a matter of negotiation, per user. That is mostly a good thing.
FM -- No static at all! (
https://youtu.be/wdoCQn_Tjac?feature=shared )